Skip to main content

Quora Question: How did Bach's genius go largely unrecognised during his own lifetime?

There are a few factors at play here. You have to first recognize that the music industry in the first half of the 18th century was not what it is today. In order for a composer’s music to become well known, a pair of factors needed to come into play:

First, that composer had to have a great publisher. Publishing was expensive in those days, and involved very careful and painstaking engraving of each note and staff. It was even more costly than printing text, and significantly more expensive than hiring a team of copyists to do it by hand. So, the publisher needed a really REALLY good reason to run things to print and distribute them.

Oh, also, distribution was a horse and carriage. So again, really expensive. And SLOW.

By the time Bach reached his apex as a composer, there were composers of secular music (Vivaldi, Handel, et al) who had better publishing deals and better court appointments. Bach was a church musician first and foremost, and by this time the style he was using for church and organ music was already out of fashion. It would be hard enough to sell on that merit alone.

So, when we look at someone like Handel, who had a fantastic English court appointment, or Vivaldi, who was also a great violinist and had a host of operatic artists at his disposal, the difference was stark. These two could go on tour to promote their music. They could wow the crowds with their performances and spectacular operas without risking their position (or leaving their wives at home with 20+ kids to look after). Tours took YEARS. With up to two weeks of travel time between major cities, it was common for touring artists to stay in one place for several months to get as much coverage from the audience as they could. Bach didn’t have that luxury.

Bach had to be at work every Sunday, and he had to be writing harmonies and cantatas on a weekly basis. It was a great gig in terms of the work and pay…he made a decent living and put out a ton of amazing music. But it was also highly restrictive, kept him out of the public eye, and kept him rather unfashionable.

That’s a great combination for a church musician, but it doesn’t exactly woo the publishers or put your music in front of throngs of adoring fans.

Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Review | Donner "Giant Metal" Distortion Pedal

Insane sound from a mini pedal After years of scaling back to just my amp tone, I've started getting back into guitar pedals. 20 years ago, if you couldn't afford the Boss or DOD pedals, you were forced to go with the only budget brand out there: Rocktek. Those things were awful, but affordable. These days, the budget brands are king, in my opinion, and the compact size of the circuitry makes it possible to grab anything you want and try it out for less than fifty bucks. I wanted to start out with a good distortion, and after playing around with online reviews I decided to take the leap to the Donner Giant Metal. This little powerhouse lives up to its name! Super solid aluminum construction, easy to use controls, a fairly wide gain profile, and surprisingly flexible tonal control. It just has the one tone control, and the switch boosts highs or lows (top or bottom), or runs right down the middle. I won't say that this can replace a high-end Boss distortion, but if y
Post a Comment
Read more

Legendary Origins: finding identity in the mythology of leaving “wildness” for agriculture

When I was working as the marketing arm for Dr. Brenda E.F. Beck’s animated series, The Legend of Ponnivala , I was struck by an interesting idea that hadn’t occurred to me before in the legends I had studied: that origin stories very often have their roots in the ancestral shift from hunter-gatherer to agricultural society. In the Ponnivala story (which is an English adaptation of the local Tamil legend, Annanmar Kathai , or “The Brothers’ Story”), there is a region of forest that the goddess Parvati wishes to see become fertile and productive, and so she creates nine men who will be the farmers of this land. Now, from the perspective of a people who have farmed the region for many hundreds, if not thousands, of years, this makes sense; taking virgin land and taming it to feed the people is a reasonable expenditure of effort. Except, this is the South Indian jungle we’re talking about. Can there be any doubt that this dense forest was already “fertile and productive” before being cle
Post a Comment
Read more

Dark is the Raven's Wing: Performance Note

"Dark is the Raven's Wing" single NOW AVAILABLE for download on Bandcamp The song "Dark is the Raven's Wing" is the title track from Kim Erickson's incredibly masterful 2015 album, The Raven's Wing (which you must absolutely add to your collection immediately, here: https://www.kimerickson.ca/ )  With the string arrangements by the remarkably versatile Joseph Phillips (from whom I did borrow a few notes for my cover arrangement), the whole album is just a stunning triumph of poetry, lyricism, and warmly genuine musicality. Erickson's performance has a sort of intentional melancholy; a practiced whimsy, like a Merchant-Ivory production of an Edith Piaf fever dream. It has deep, deep joy that is wrapped in a shawl of nostalgia hinting at sorrow; a hiraeth ; a Welsh term for that longing we have to return to an ancient home from the distant past that perhaps never even existed in reality. This is the evocation I get from “Dark is the Raven’s Wing.”
Post a Comment
Read more